Summary
Between February 2017 to December 2018, the National Crime Agency (NCA) obtained Account Freezing Orders (AFOs) totalling £190 million against Pakistani businessman Malik Riaz Hussain and his son, Ahmed Ali Riaz, in relation to property that was alleged to be the proceeds of crime.
Malik Riaz is the founder and chairman of Bahria Town Limited, a privately owned real-estate company that develops and manages property in Pakistan. There have been a number of allegations against Bahria Town about its involvement in corruption, bribery, land grabbing and financial irregularities, with an investigation prompted by the Supreme Court of Pakistan finding evidence of money laundering.
This case represents some of the biggest ever Account Freezing Orders secured by the NCA. However, rather than following through with forfeiture proceedings, the NCA announced in December 2019 that it had reached a settlement with the family of Malik Riaz. With Malik Riaz agreeing to hand over a total £190 million in assets, this represents the National Crime Agency’s (NCA) largest asset recovery.
However, the details of this settlement were not made public, and a tweet from Malik Riaz indicates that the seized assets in question were used to pay off the Bahria Town Karachi settlement in Pakistan. Following the AFOs and subsequent settlement, the Home Office moved to cancel the 10-year multiple entry visit visas of Malik Riaz and Ahmed Riaz. This cited their involvement in “corruption and financial/commercial misconduct” in a decision that was upheld by the Court of Appeal.
On 9 May 2023, the former Prime Minister of Pakistan, Imran Khan, was arrested on charges of corruption, where it was alleged that he was involved in a ‘Quid Pro Quo’ with Malik Riaz in relation to the Bahria Town case – allegations both Khan and Riaz deny. The fact that this settlement has become central to the political turmoil currently taking place in Pakistan should give the NCA reason to review whether settlements in cases of Kleptocracy are ever really suitable.
Why does this case matter?
- The outcome of this case is important in determining whether the aims of the civil recovery regime have been undermined by the NCA’s move to settle following the use of the AFO’s. This casts doubts on the effectiveness of the AFO regime in tackling the proceeds of international corruption being laundered in the UK. The nature of the settlement and the lack of transparency around it raises serious concerns. AFOs are not and should not be treated as a bilateral deal between two parties. They are a civil recovery tool used to target the proceeds of crime in a rapid way, depriving criminals of the benefit of their wrongdoing (but they do not actually establish criminal behaviour). In tackling the perception of the UK as a haven for dirty money, effective recovery of assets is just as important as other criminal penalties, as it decreases the viability of such operations within the UK. How these proceeds of crime are dealt with is a matter of public interest.
- In this case, little to no information has been made available as to how the frozen assets have been distributed, and whether this has been done so in line with the settlement. The alleged proceeds of corruption being repurposed to pay penalties for that corruption severely undermines the effectiveness of the AFO regime. Money that has been forfeited is going back to pay for the illegal acquisition of land and evicting of local communities. It was also held that the settlement did “not represent a finding of guilt”, which gives more of a scope to respond and negotiate to those being investigated. It seems that the NCA ignored the possibility of the re-corruption of funds and chose to wash its hands of the matter. It might be suggested that the NCA was pressured to act in this way due to the political sensitivity of this case and not wanting to upset a sovereign country. However, in doing so the NCA not only allowed Malik Riaz to uphold his reputation, claim innocence, and offset his losses illegitimately, but has now also involved itself in the very serious political tension in Pakistan.
- The UK has long subscribed to the GFAR principles. The outcome of this case seems hypocritical after the UK tried to take the lead on tackling corruption. The case highlights the issue of the return of stolen assets to origin countries. The UK is required to return the proceeds of crime to the requesting state where the necessary conditions are satisfied. This new framework came into effect after the Malik Riaz case, but is drawn from the GFAR principles in place at the time of the case. The case highlights the need for consideration of the re-corruption of funds, and perhaps the need to implement mechanisms to prevent this.
- The Home Office’s decision to cancel the multi-entry visit visas of Malik Riaz and Ahmed Ali Riaz on corruption grounds was a positive move, but it only came in January 2020, after law enforcement action against Malik Riaz had been settled. The Court of Appeal, with reference to the AFO applications, upheld this decision on judicial review. The lack of transparency in the settlement is compounded by the fact that the underlying court documents are not readily available. Open justice is essential for allowing public scrutiny of the decisions taken in this case, particularly now that this case sits at the centre of political allegations with global implications. Historically, there have been issues surrounding visas granted on the basis of wealth, such as the ‘Golden Visa’ regime, which effectively invited dirty money into the UK until the route was belatedly closed in February 2022. However, the issues surrounding this regime have not been fully addressed. It is essential that the Home Office strengthens its immigration function with specialist financial and economic crime expertise to ensure dirty money does not enter the UK.
Global context
The corruption allegations central to this case concern controversial property developments by Bahria Town in Pakistan.
The son of Malik Riaz, Ahmed Ali Riaz Malik, (who was named in the Panama Papers), serves as the current CEO of Bahria Town, and along with his wife, Mubashara Ali Malik, were also subject to AFOs. One of the development projects run by Bahria Town is the Bahria Town Karachi (BTK) project; a gated suburb in northeast Karachi.
The Malir Development Authority (MDA) is a government body that was created for the development of areas in Karachi. In this instance, the MDA was given a grant of 9,385 acres of land for the development of ‘incremental housing’. Instead, the MDA exchanged this land for land owned by BTK.
In 2018 the Supreme Court of Pakistan launched an inquiry into the exchange of land between BTK and the MDA. The Court held that transfer of land was illegal and thus void. It was alleged that BTK exchanged relatively worthless land in return for land prime for development – that there was a defrauding of the government. As a result, BTK was forbidden from selling plots, and the land transfer was to be cancelled. However, Bahria Town Limited eventually came to an agreement in which they would pay Rs460b (approximately £2b at the time) to settle the case.
The local community in Karachi were the victims of BTK’s crime, as they would have benefitted from the development, had their local government not been defrauded. It is interesting then, that BTK asked to pay the fine to the Sindh government. The Sindh government, who previously echoed the view of BTK that they didn’t suffer a loss, also requested that they should be the recipient of these funds. While the court ultimately did receive the fine amount, this speaks to the influence that a wealthy businessman like Malik Riaz has over government officials – and the issues with preventing the re-corruption of funds.
This follows a pattern of corrupt and unethical behaviour carried out by BTK with the help of local government and authorities. In separate proceedings, the “Joint Investigation Team”, was instructed by the Supreme Court of Pakistan to investigate matters of bribery and money laundering. Their investigation found a number of suspicious transactions, and an operation involving the laundering of proceeds of crime, particularly in relation to land grabbing; which is also raising broader humanitarian concerns for the local community, especially with regard to the forceful uprooting of indigenous groups. This serves as a powerful illustration of the harms of corruption.
This case also highlights the problem of alleged corruption at the highest levels of government. The government of Pakistan seemed reluctant to share details of the NCA recovery, and it was reported that cabinet ministers were asked to approve documents related to this settlement without being made aware of its contents.
More recently, the corruption is alleged to have spread to the very top of the government. The former Prime Minister, Imran Khan was accused of accepting bribes from Malik Riaz in return for protection in a money laundering case against Bahria Town, including a donation of land to the Al-Qadir Trust, founded by Khan. A number of senior politicians were summoned by the National Accountability Bureau in connection with the case, and Khan himself was arrested by army rangers. Khan denies these allegations.
Irrespective of whether these allegations have weight, they raise further serious questions about whether the NCA took robust enough action in response to allegations of wrongdoing, to ensure those implicated in corruption did not benefit from the terms of the settlement.
The case in the UK
The NCA’s frozen funds investigation
Over a series of AFOs, the NCA froze £190 million in assets. Reference was made specifically in the application documents to the state of the combined cash assets of Ahmed Ali Riaz Malik and his wife Mubashara Ali Malik. From February 2017 to December 2018, there was a substantial increase in the amount of cash they held in the UK from £56.9m to £138.5m. This, “when considered alongside the political and judicial developments in Pakistan”, was argued to be “highly suspicious and suggestive of attempts to conceal the proceeds of criminal conduct”.
On 14 December 2018, the district judge at Westminster Magistrates Crown Court granted an AFO worth £20m, under the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002. This was in connection with the transfer of £19.999m by Mubashara Ali Malik from a personal account in the UAE to ‘Premier Investments Global Ltd’, a company account in relation to which Mubashara Ali Malik and Ahmed Ali Riaz Malik were identified as the ultimate beneficial owners. As part of its broader frozen funds investigation, the NCA identified further assets, including “a substantial United Kingdom property portfolio, property in the United Arab Emirates and substantial liquid assets in both jurisdictions”.
On 12 August 2019, the NCA was granted 8 further AFOs in relation to accounts held by Ali Malik and other family members. This put the total value of the frozen sums at £140m. One of these AFOs was against property owned by Ultimate Holdings Mgt Ltd, a company beneficially owned by Ahmed Ali Riaz Malik and Mubashra Ali Malik.
Settlement with the NCA:
On 3 December 2019, the NCA issued a statement announcing that it had reached a confidential £190m settlement in its investigation of Malik Riaz. This involved the funds frozen in the December 2018 and August 2019 AFOs, as well as a UK property valued at £50m. The property in question is located at 1 Hyde Park Place (W2 2LH). Interestingly, this property first came to the attention in the Panama Papers leak of 2016, where it was revealed that the property belonged to Hasan Nawaz Sharif, the son of the former Prime Minister of Pakistan Nawaz Sharif. Following the Panama Paper leaks, a Joint Investigation Team was tasked by the Supreme Court of Pakistan to investigate offshore assets held by the Sharif family. Nawaz Sharif was consequently sentenced to 7 years in jail by an anti-corruption court.
The 1 Hyde Park property was owned by Ultimate Holdings. The NCA settlement only related to the 1 Hyde Park property, but the NCA application made reference to a wider property portfolio. If this portfolio was built up through the proceeds of corruption, it is not clear why the NCA settlement did not also include these properties.
While the terms of the settlement with the NCA are not public, it appears to have been agreed that £190m would be “given to the state of Pakistan”, and specifically stated that there was not a “finding of guilt”. The settlement being wrapped in so much secrecy makes it hard to evaluate whether the NCA’s reasons for reaching the agreement were sound, and whether it sought to ensure safeguards were in place for how the returned assets would be used. Rather than achieving the aim of civil recovery in permanently depriving criminals of their ill-gotten gains, there is a real risk that the funds returned have been repurposed to benefit corrupt actors.
It is also interesting to note that the NCA’s investigation took account of political and judicial developments within Pakistan when assessing the financial flows under scrutiny, which perhaps lends credence to the idea that they were influenced by external pressure in keeping the terms of the settlement silent.
Visa Revocation and Judicial Review:
Malik Riaz and Ali Riaz held 10-year multi entry visas, which were valid until mid-2021. These were cancelled by the Secretary of State for the Home Office on 10 December 2019, with “regard to the UKs commitment to combat corruption and financial crime”.
This decision was challenged, and the Home Office, relying on the court proceedings in Pakistan, as well as the AFOs obtained, reached the same conclusion in regard to “corruption and/or financial/commercial misconduct”. This finding was challenged through judicial review and was upheld at both first instance and at the Court of Appeal.
While it should be applauded that the Home Office took action to cancel the visas, this was only after being confronted with clear evidence of corruption and law enforcement action. This suggests that the Home Office immigration function lacks the capacity and expertise to effectively stem the tide of dirty money into the UK. Considering the fallout from the golden visa being shut down, there are questions about what steps the Home Office is taking to mitigate the economic crime and national security risks posed by its past failure to do proper checks on visa applicants.
A final point to consider is the extent to which the NCA settled with Malik Riaz because of the fear that they would be buried in litigation costs. As it currently stands, law enforcement has some cost protection if they lose a case, but not in the high courts or elsewhere. In Parliament, the economic crime and corporate transparency bill is currently going through final stages. Spotlight has campaigned for an amendment to provide cost protection to law enforcement authorities in civil recovery cases.
